Notorious P.I.E.
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Notorious P.I.E. Menu

Menu Notorious P.I.E.-1
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-1
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-2
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-2
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-3
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-3
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-4
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-4
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-5
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-5
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-6
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-6
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-7
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-7
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-8
Menu Notorious P.I.E.-8

Greens

Plain Jane
$7.50
Romaine and spinach, carrots, cucumber, croutons, tomatoes, choice of dressing.
Banana Pepper Caesar
$8.75
Romaine and spinach, croutons, Parmesan, and fried pepperoni.
Chicken Caesar Salad
$13.00
A slightly lighter version of our banana pepper caesar with chicken breast.

Sandwiches

Hot Italian Beef Sandwich
$13.75
Hot SubHouse roasted beef sliced thin and piled high. Topped with giardiniera peppers served with au jus and potato chips on the side. Add provolone, roasted onions, or sauted crimini mushrooms for an additional charge.
The Caprese Sandwich
$11.00
Cold SubVegetarian. Fresh mozzarella, roasted tomato, fresh fennel, red onion, orange vinaigrette, pesto, fresh basil.
The Roasted Vegan Sandwich
$12.50
Cold SubVegan. Roasted carrot hummus, cucumber, roasted onion, banana peppers, roasted tomato, kalamata olives, spinach, roasted red peppers, garlic and basil infused olive oil. Served with chips.
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
$13.75
Hot SubCrispy chicken topped with red sauce, provolone, parmesan, and fresh basil. Served with chips.
The Submarine Sandwich
$10.50
Hot SubGenoa salami, pepperoni, ham, lettuce, tomato, roasted onion, balsamic & orange vinaigrette.
Who You Calling Turkey
$11.00
Cold SubRoasted turkey, honey mustard, provolone, romaine, spinach, red onion, cherry tomatoes.
Turkey Bacon Ranch
$11.00
Cold SubTurkey, bacon jam, ranch, provolone, lettuce, cherry tomatoes
Italian Garden
$11.25
Cold sub. Provolone, ricotta cream, roasted tomatoes, garlic, balsamic glaze, fresh basil. Served with chips.

Munchies

Best Boneless Wings
$13.75
Choice of sauce: traditional buffalo, Jamaican jerk, or sweet and spicy ginger garlic. Served with carrots and bleu cheese dressing.
Notorious Bruschetta
$7.50
Vegetarian. Crostinis topped with house ricotta cream, roasted tomato, fresh basil, and balsamic glaze drizzle.
Hummus Duo
$7.50
Vegan. Two scoops of roasted carrot hummus, served with crostinis and carrots.
Fried Cheese
$8.75
Vegetarian. Served with house red sauce.
Bomb Snacks
$5.00
Fried dough balls stuffed with cheese blend, sausage, pepperoni, and garnished with Parmesan.
Garlic Bread
$3.75
Served with house red sauce
Garlic Cheese Bread
$6.25
Served with house red sauce.

Single Slice

Pepperoni Slice
$5.00
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, and pepperoni.
Cheese Slice
$5.00
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend
Fried Cheese Slice
$6.00
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, more red sauce, fried cheese, and fresh basil.
Deep Dish Cured Meat Overlord Slice
$6.00
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, garlic, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, italian sausage, bacon on our deep dish Chicago-style crust.

Notorious P.I.E.S

Cured Meat Overlord Pie
$33.75
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, pepperoni, Italian sausage, chopped bacon, Canadian bacon, roasted tomatoes, and garlic.
The Deluxe Pie
$32.50
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, roasted onions, and mushrooms.
Big Peppa Pie
$30.00
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, 90 pepperonis, and fried pepperoni crumbles.
Always Know Your Dealer Pie
$32.50
Vegetarian. Ricotta cream, five cheese blend, sauted crimini mushrooms, fresh crimini mushrooms, spinach, and parmesan.
The Screamin' Vegan Pie
$35.00
Vegan. Sauted crimini mushrooms, roasted onion, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives, and artichoke hearts.
The Fatter Tony Pie
$33.75
Red sauce, garlic, 5 cheese blend, pepperoni, sausage, roasted onion, more red sauce, and Parmesan.
Gluten Free Pies
$11.00
Individual 8" cauliflower crust. While the crust is gluten-free, we are not a gluten-free kitchen. We do not guarantee that the crust will not come into contact with flour.
Sausage Pie
$23.75
Red sauce, five cheese blend, sausage.
Pepperoni Pie
$23.75
Red sauce, five cheese blend, pepperonis.
Cheese Pie
$21.25
Red sauce, five cheese blend.
The Real Real Pie
$33.75
Ricotta cream, 5 cheese blend, chicken breast, crimini mushrooms, spinach, artichoke hearts, and balsamic glaze.
Fried Cheese Pizza
$31.25
Red sauce, 5 cheese blend, more red sauce, fried cheese, Parmesan, and fresh basil.
Run Through the Garden Pie
$30.00
Red sauce, five cheese blend, roasted onions, roasted red peppers, crimini mushrooms, Kalamata olives, and spinach.
Margherita Pie
$23.00
Vegetarian. Red sauce, roasted tomatoes, garlic, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$32.50
Ricotta ranch, five cheese blend, fried chicken, fresh tomatoes, bacon, ranch drizzle
Pepperoni Jalapeno
$26.25
Red sauce, five cheese blend, pepperoni, jalapeno.
Hawaiian Heat
$27.50
Red sauce, five cheese blend, canadian bacon, pineapple, jalapenos.

Be a Boss - Build Your Own

Build Your Own
$21.25

Refreshments

Fountain Drinks
$2.75
Sweet Tea
$2.75
Iced Tea
$2.75
Red Bull
$4.00
Topo Chico
$3.00

Juicy Juicy Juice

Orange Juice
$4.00

Dessert

Cheesecake
$8.75
New York Style Cheesecake
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.50
Gluten FreeFresh Baked Cookie.
White Chocolate Cranberry Cookie
$1.50
Fresh Baked

Dipping Sauces

Ranch
$0.25
Ricotta Ranch
$0.35
Red Sauce
$0.35
Buffalo Sauce
$0.35
Sweet & Spicy Ginger Garlic
$0.35
Bleu Cheese
$0.35
Jamaican Jerk
$0.35

Notorious P.I.E. offers a bold and flavorful menu that caters to every craving, from vibrant greens to indulgent pies. The Greens section is fresh and crisp, featuring the Plain Jane Salad for those who appreciate simplicity, the zesty Banana Pepper Caesar, and the protein-packed Chicken Caesar Salad for a satisfying meal.

The Sandwiches are a showstopper, with options like the savory Hot Italian Beef Sandwich, the light and fresh Caprese Sandwich, and the hearty Chicken Parmesan Sandwich. For something more adventurous, try the Roasted Vegan Sandwich or the classic Submarine Sandwich, both packed with bold flavors and textures.

When it comes to Munchies, you’re in for a treat with the Best Boneless Wings, crispy and flavorful, the rich and tangy Notorious Bruschetta, and the perfectly creamy Hummus Duo. If you're in the mood for something indulgent, the Fried Cheese and addictive Bomb Snacks will hit the spot.

The Single Slices are perfect for a quick bite, with favorites like the classic Pepperoni Slice, creamy Cheese Slice, and crispy Fried Cheese Slice. For a more robust experience, the Deep Dish Cured Meat Overlord Slice brings layers of flavor in every bite.

Of course, the star of the show is the array of Notorious P.I.E.S. From the carnivorous Cured Meat Overlord Pie to the hearty Deluxe Pie and fiery Big Peppa Pie, there’s something for everyone. For those craving a plant-based option, the Screamin' Vegan Pie will leave you satisfied.

Don’t forget to wash it down with a cold Fountain Drink, refreshing Sweet Tea, or an energizing Red Bull. For dessert, indulge in a rich Cheesecake or freshly baked Chocolate Chip Cookie, and don't miss the sweet and tart White Chocolate Cranberry Cookie.

For extra flavor, dive into an array of Dipping Sauces, including Ranch, Buffalo Sauce, and the unique Sweet & Spicy Ginger Garlic. Each bite is designed to excite your taste buds and keep you coming back for more.

Notorious P.I.E.

Notorious P.I.E. in Norman, OK offers a unique twist on pizza with vegan and vegetarian options. Enjoy a laid-back atmosphere with happy hour specials, full bar, and outdoor seating. Try their delicious boneless wings or famous bruschetta. Customer reviews rave about the amazing crust and friendly staff. Don't miss out on this local gem!

Follow Us
  • facebook
  • Yelp
  • instagram
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.